A while ago I created a nightmare-fuel image of what a mouse would look like if there were a species that looked like our favorite jamboree-leading rodent, Mickey Mouse.

After everyone was done cringing and dry heaving, I put the question to our readers of which iconic cartoon animal I should do next. The options were the Pink Panther, Care Bears, Bugs Bunny and My Little Pony (which won by a surprising landslide). Here’s your next creep-fest.

Since I did the original digitally mutated mouse, I’ve discovered a bunch of other pixel wizards had the same idea and “untooned” other iconic cartoon characters. I promise you, not ALL of them will give you nightmares. Most, but not all.
 

Homer J. Simpson

Source: Pixeloo
 

Mr. Burns

Source: Matalone
 

Mario (Super Mario Bros.)

Source: Pixeloo
 

Beavis & Butthead

Source: Worth 1000
 

Popeye

Source: Rick Baker Digital Art
 

Patrick Star
(SpongeBob SquarePants)

Source: unknown
 

Stewie Griffin (Family Guy)

Source: Pixeloo
 

Peter Griffin (Family Guy)

Source: Worth 1000
 

Charlie Brown

Source: unknown
 

Prof Farnsworth (Futurama)

Source: unknown
 

Fred Flintstone

Source: unknown
 

Shaggy (Scooby-Doo)

Source: unknown
 

Buzz Lightyear (Toy Story)

Source: Source: Raoni Nery
 

Jessica Rabbit (Who Framed Roger Rabbit?)

Source: Pixeloo
 

A Smurf

Source: Nate Hallinan