Two Beds, or Not Two Beds…

Posted under NOTEBOOK

Two beds separate beds for married couples

Two beds, or not two beds, that is the question. To sleep separately, perchance to dream…

I’m a side sleeper. At least that’s how I fall asleep. Apparently the way I land and spend the rest of the night is a more varied and active endeavor. Lizzie has informed me repeatedly that I actually sleep on my back, when I’m not performing ice skating Triple Lutzes, and that I make “noises.” Not typical snoring noises, like the Harley-Davidson company made a chainsaw for cutting down petrified trees””she really hesitates to even use the word “snoring.” Apparently it’s more like the sound you would expect to hear after a cruel kid dropped his commemorative souvenir toy into the blow hole of a dolphin in the petting tank at Sea World. Lots of wheezing hisses and tormented sucking sounds. Awful. I’m not employing my imagination in describing this, I’ve listened to the recorded memo from my evidence-minded wife’s cellphone.

One day she blew me away by suddenly asking, “What if we got separate beds?” After my senses returned to me, I might have said something about saving some money by buying a gun and using it on me. Comfy beds are kinda pricey compared to a handgun.

My life’s thoughts on the subject flashed before my eyes…

Separate bed in marriageDesi loved Lucy. But he did it from a wholesome distance.

When I was a kid…

As a kid, I’d watch spouses, in black and white, tucking themselves into separate beds with a peck on the cheek, and I figured they just didn’t love each other very much in the olden days or were at least very official about it in their satin PJs.

The Age of Teen…

Even as a freshly minted teenager I knew enough about sex that you’re pretty much occupying the same footprint when making the beast with two backs, so when it came to “love” if you needed something bigger than a twin you were either doing it wrong or doing it extremely right. So maybe it wasn’t about a cold distance between bedfellows.

Later that decade…

I later found out that this separate bed thing in film and TV was mostly about censorship that had a yard long rod shoved up its… regulations. You weren’t allowed to depict a married couple sleeping in the same bed. Kind of like Jeannie’s covered up naval in I Dream of Jeannie. Apparently all this was supposed to curtail the blindness caused by masturbation and thwart sexual tendencies in teenagers. Or it was some held over tradition from the aristocracy sleeping in separate bedrooms so they could have affairs with their cousins while butlers were busy stabbing someone in their sleep. But that might have just been too many Masterpiece Theater murder mysteries skewing my perspective.

Fast forward to present day…

My jaw is still sort of hanging open about the suggestion that we get two beds. The fact that we have a California King just adds insult to injury. There’s just nowhere to go bigger than that unless we slept in an inflatable moon bounce.

cosleeping with babyHow could anyone break this up? It just doesn’t work on twin beds.

I know that my wife’s very life force is being extracted from her body by way of her boobs and she needs her sleep. I know that tormented dolphins performing bad break dancing in bed doesn’t really support great sleep… there’s that catchy expression: “Happy wife, happy life. Angry mother… you’re dead.” Or something. But I’m still sort of stung. In addition to being incredibly discouraging to me about the state of our union, it seemed like such a humiliating suggestion and I couldn’t even imagine telling other people or friends. “Oh sure, we decided to go with separate beds an’ all. Oh yeah! It’s great! She gets so much more sleep now, it’s fantastic. You know what else? I had my pesky testicles removed, too. Oh yeah! They were always getting in the way, just jangling around to and fro, and when you sit down wrong! Hoo hoo! Lemme tell ya! Well, those days are gone!”

“Present statistics” can shut the Hell up!

The present statistics on the subject of marriage may tell you that separate beds are on the rise, 1 out of 4 and all that jazz, snoring being the main reason followed by sleep gymnastics, mumbling and talking. Personally I think these are all amazing, like nighttime super powers. But, alas, Lizzie is not of the same mind, and when she is jackhammering me with a poking finger because I’m snorkeling poorly in my sleep, I can’t help but worry the next morning she’ll say, “Remember that question I asked you a while ago?…”

I just think back on nights where she’d woken me up because she couldn’t sleep because I’d rolled away and wasn’t touching her. And now? Two beds? She hasn’t pursued it, but I can’t really tell whether it’s because she now doesn’t think it would be a good idea or because of the “orphaned kitten sitting on a rainy doorstep” look that I gave her when she suggested it.

If your eyeballs aren’t worn out from reading… We’ve got lots more.

If your eyeball ARE worn out from reading… Give them a break with some pictures.

46 Comments

  • Liesbet says:

    My boyfriend sleeps very badly. He wakes up easily and always too early. Even when he sleeps alone.
    So when I started snoring loudly during my pregnancy, he started using wax earplugs… and never stopped using them since. Our daughter is 14 months old now, and B. has worn earplugs every single night. I don’t care, cause I’m asleep too anyway.
    If ever I start dancing in my sleep or if someday he develops a tendency of hitting me in his sleep, we’ll get separate beds. Less cozy, that’s true. But sleep is SO important for both of us…

    • taylor says:

      the bizarre sleep habits of pregnant wives could be a whole post on its own! My wife used no less than 6 pillows to build up an impenetrable fortress of nocturnal dozery. In addition, somebody told her that if she didn’t sleep on her left side, and left side only our kid would come out with 3 arms, or boils or a guido. With the wife on her left side this made me the little spoon for 9 months! If I resisted then we were stuck with breathing in each other’s faces all night.

    • andy says:

      That’s the thing, I can sleep on the top of a train pulling boxcars loaded with a million bicycle bells, at full speed while on fire. Lizzie is a very light sleeper. It doesn’t matter if I’m too loud or she’s too sensitive, we’ve got each other.

      Maybe we’ll try the ear plugs for her and a ball gag for me just to keep things fair. Ha ha!

  • Ben Martin says:

    When I’ve heard of the two-bed solution offered because of snoring, I usually wonder what in the world it is expected to change. A person snoring in the same room is just as loud whether they’re in the same bed or a different one. The only logical course of action, then, would be two bedrooms, and then you’re really introducing some weird dynamics into the marriage. I don’t get it.

    • andy says:

      That’s a good point. Maybe it’s so she’s got more room for a wind-up pitch when she needs to throw a slipper at me. πŸ˜‰

  • Beth Anne says:

    I am horribly torn on the subject.

    On one hand, I am Team Lizzie because dude? EVERY NIGHT WITH THE SNORING. & the cover-stealing. & the inability to agree on the type of sheets, amount of pillows, warmth of comforter.

    But sleeping without my huz? Cannot fathom it. My child growing up in a home where his parents don’t sleep in the same bed? Kinda makes my heart-piece hurt.

    I think we’ll stick it out for now, but we may need to upgrade to a King sooner rather than later (we’re in a queen).

    • andy says:

      Completely agreed. I forgot to write about the kids, the effect I would worry about it having on them. “No little guys. It’s not because we don’t love each other any more, it’s just ’cause Mommy and Daddy just love each like they did in ’50s television shows now.” ARG!!!

      How did you know she also considers me a cover hog and we also have bedding debates??? GET OUT OF OUR MINDS!!! (putting on a tinfoil hat)

    • Rachel says:

      XD I’m the cover stealer in my relationship. We solved that one by each of us having our own sheets and covers. If you’re the kind of person who likes the sheets all nice and tucked in, I’m sure it doesn’t work, but for me, having my own cover means never waking up in the middle of the night trying to wrestle it away from the hubby. And he’s never shivering off to the side because I’ve decided that half the blanket needs to act as a buffer between my knobby knees. It also doesn’t disturb us as much when the other rolls over or tosses and turns because they aren’t moving your covers with them. ^_^;;

      As for the separate bed thing…it just seems like the first step (albeit in a long line of steps) to the big D. I’m with you. I actually have a hard time falling asleep if hubby isn’t there. You get used to someone sleeping next to you and making noises at night!

  • jessi says:

    But think of how awesome it would be to say “lets pull the beds together tonight babe” πŸ˜‰ lmao

    • andy says:

      Good point. There is no arguing with that awesomeness. Add a motor and a remote control and we’re talking the home planet of Awesome.

  • I was on vacation recently in a rented house, and the room we slept in had two full size beds that had been pushed together with a funky frame to hold them in place. Not the first time I’d seen that setup, but i inquired anyway. Apparently, the house was owned by two older people who slept separately, but the new owner (their daughter) pushed them together because she thought vacationing couples should sleep together. I agree with her.

    • Desiree says:

      I have been in that set-up before. I always ended up falling slowly into the abyss as I slept, being the cuddler that I am.

      • andy says:

        Yeah, I’m a Journey to the Center of the Bed kind of cuddler/bed vagabond. I don’t do well with the San Andreas fault between my wife and me.

    • andy says:

      I agree with her too. I’m not a picky person, but I’m not sure I agree with her that her vacationing guests should sleep in two old peoples beds that have been pushed together in a funky frame. Ha ha!

      • Yeah, it was kind of weird because they had family photos all around. I get the personal touch thing, makes it different than staying at a hotel, but seeing pictures of aunt judy and the grandkids through the years was a bit too much.

  • mikes says:

    I think there are very few things that make a marriage more than just a friendship, and sleeping in the same bed is one of them.

    FWIW, I’ve had the same experiences:
    – I can’t go to sleep without you holding me
    – You’re keeping me awake with those noises
    —> both in the same night

    Unfortunately, I think the likely solution to your problem is to have a sleep study done and possibly get a CPAP. You’d probably sleep much more calmly… if nothing else you’ll become trained not to move so much by the mask being repeatedly ripped off your face. πŸ˜‰

    Either way, Good luck man!

    • andy says:

      Holy cramoley! That sounds pretty Silence of the Lambs, sleeping with a mask. I know that Lizzie wouldn’t go for that at all. Plus, the tearing it off my face would probably come more from our co-sleeping son, Lucas, then my acro- and aerobatics.

      We’ll tough it out, but I’ll take your offered luck! Thanks, man.

  • Chris says:

    Two beds.

    Sleep is paramount. My wife snores heavily, so do I (@#$ adnoids!). As parents of a *very* energetic two year old, we both need our sleep for obvious reasons.

    I have thought about separate beds. It’s weird. It made me feel like a lousy husband and our marriage was on the rocks. Neither of which is true, I’ve been told.

    She’ll sleep, you’ll sleep. Your life will improve for the better.

    Two beds.

  • Chris says:

    I forgot to mention…

    Tell her to get a white noise machine and put it between your beds.

    It’ll act as sound baffle.

    • andy says:

      I am white noise! That’s the problem. I sound like a dentist’s suction hose or this:

      sleestak snoring

  • John says:

    There have been studies done that show how this does not help marriages last. I would agree with the people who said to get a sleep test and fix the snoring.

    • andy says:

      It’s not really snoring though. It’s like I’m soul kissing myself apparently, trying to swallow my own tongue. I know it amounts to the same thing medically maybe, but… (sigh).

  • Desiree says:

    First, try seeing whether nutrition is the culprit. Cut out dairy, and I’ll bet you don’t snorkel anymore. Plus, there are supplements for overly active nighttime motion. Try taking some supplements like B Complex in the morning and Natural Calm and Sleep Release right before you sleep. Both of you could probably take the Natural Calm – because a new mom sleeps either like the dead or ready to wake at a moment’s notice, with no in between. Sounds like she’s a very light sleeper.

    Then, get a comfy daybedish thing – a fold-into-a-couch sort of thing for one wall of your bedroom and have her poke you out of bed when you become a problem for her.

    I’m not a doctor though. Ask a naturopath for help. Because that snorkel thing? Can be dangerous to leave untreated. It’s funny or obnoxious, yes. But that’s secondary to that it’s a real health issue to make sure you’re getting enough oxygen when you sleep, and that noise is your body having to go to olympic lengths to keep you from turning blue.

    My take? Don’t make a habit of a second place to sleep, but do provide a second place to crash, so she stays sane when it gets too much.

    Good luck.

    • andy says:

      The words “cutting out dairy” hits my mind as “cutting out (your organ of choice)”! Sorry, lactose intolerant people reading this. There are people out there who are not just tolerant of lactose, but who thrive on it.

      We are going to do a rollaway or fold-up or otherwise retractible Swiss Army bed of some sort, if just for visiting guests. We’ll probably use that when I’m particularly noisy. And, YES, totally agree on it not being a permanent arrangement or regular routine.

  • Kristin says:

    My husband and I had the same issues, cover stealing, restless leg syndrome that almost made me kill him, and the snoring. When I got pregnant I’d had it and made him go to the doctor who sent him for a sleep study, turns out he has Sleep Apnea. They prescribed a CPAP machine and all the problems went away except for blanket stealing, and I solved that by using two separate twin bed comforters on a king size bed. Now it’s completely peaceful in our bedroom.

    • andy says:

      Good going! Yeah, I think the separate covers is a pretty nifty way to go.

  • Charlie says:

    I was a “tosser and turner” as well as a snorer, and heres the solution that worked for my wife and I. Back in March we bought an adjustable bed (we got the Cloud Luxe Tempurpedic on Advanced Ergo bases). Sleeping with your head inclined actually opens your airways, preventing the blockages caused by sleeping on your back — Therefoore elimating the snoring. And the Tempurpedic keeps you from tossing and turning so much throughout the night.

    Yes it was expensive, but it’s the first and only time my 8 month pregnant wife has called me a genius since i’ve known her. I’d say that makes it all worth it. Most places offer 0% interest financing options and a trial period — so if it doesn’t work, you can return it. Good luck!

  • Kit says:

    well me and my husband did this actually when we first moved in together. we had two queens so we’re like what the heck lets use both! why toss a perfectly good bed. this was after him staying with me for 6 months but nothing official. we had him doing the robot in bed he wanted a bunch of covers, i didn’t. and there may have been a time i back handed him on accident *ahem* so the two beds was awesome for us plus it was kinda fun wiggling my eyebrows at him when i asked him to come over. i say try it see if it works, and with more sleep maybe she’ll be up for more extracirricular activities ;)there’s an incentive. i also vote for sleep study did you know sleep apnea (linked with snoring) increases your chances of cardiac issues? by quite a bit if i remember right!

  • Stephanie K. says:

    Our living room couch is sooooo comfortable! Lol! I don’t sleep there all the time, but I do when our 20 month old is doing her aerobics in bed. Jon snores but it doesn’t bug me. We have a 20 month old and 4 month old, however, and mama needs her sleep. So if my daughter is particularly restless, to the couch I go!!

  • Kippie says:

    My professional opinion? You definitely need to be tested for sleep apnea. Your wife will not mind the mask when you can both sleep in peace! Untreated sleep apnea can be deadly in severe forms, so please get checked!! You will feel much better, and your wife will be happy. What’s to lose?

    • andy says:

      What’s to lose? A lot of money, my composure from fear-mongering doctors and my mask-free sleeping habits. Ha ha! I don’t have sleep apnea. I’m familiar with the condition, I have a client that makes a related product. I just occasionally sound like a sleestak. πŸ˜‰

  • Kat says:

    My husband has been a horrific snorer for the entire time we’ve been married (and probably longer). I sent him off to see a specialist whose conclusion was that his wife is light sleeper. Just as well I didn’t attend that appointment or I swear I would have killed the man with one of his own instruments. Too many nights laying awake, delirious with exhaustion, whilst my beloved snores loud enough to be heard down the street, kind of makes me cranky like that. And it doesn’t help that he’s asleep and snoring wiithin seconds of turning off the light, whereas is takes me a good five to ten minutes of peace to gently drift off into blissful slumber – peace that I don’t get when aforementioned beloved spouse is snoring away next to me!

    Now the offspring are a little older (youngest is 3), and they only wake me two or three times a night as opposed to two or three times an hour, we’ve found the simplest way for me to get better sleep is for him to give me a headstart! He sits in bed and reads till I’m asleep then he’s at liberty to snort, whistle, wheeze and croak to his hearts content. Turns out I’m not a light sleeper – I just need a head start!

  • Lizzie says:

    OH my Lord Luv you shared this with your readers, and so honest too! πŸ˜‰
    I think there is nothing wrong with separate beds. Trust me there ain’t nothing going on between the sheets when Mama over here ain’t gettin no DAMN shuteye!

    • andy says:

      Ha ha ha ha ha ha! I know what YOU think! But Mama ain’t gettin no damn sleep when I’m in another bed neither! Ha ha!

  • Cheryl M. says:

    Sorry Andy, I’m with Lizzie on this one!

    My husband fights Matrix-style ninjas in his sleep and has literally elbow-slammed me in the face while I was sleeping. In return for the favor of being jolted to wide-awake status in extreme pain, I clocked him.

    He’s also been known to twist himself up in the blankets so quickly that I get fabric burns – yet as he’s falling asleep, he needs to be as near-naked as possible. Thus, our bedroom is at a cool 67-68, with much-needed blankets that he steals, leaving me to awaken in the Arctic zone and feeling like the dude in the movie “Iceman”.

    Now that we’ve got a 5yo and a 6mo, my sleep is so precious that anyone who isn’t under 4 feet tall who dares wake me up is risking a slow, painful death.

    So, if everyone is asleep and the elder boy has snuck into our room when hubby finally (the dope can’t seem to realize that he needs shut-eye too!) drags his butt to bed, chances are pretty good that he’ll crash in our son’s room.

    • andy says:

      LMAO! I’ve been clocked before, too. (thinking to myself) … Maybe separate beds doesn’t sound so bad…

  • Oh boy. I have one foot in each camp. I lived for years with my ex in two separate ROOMS, not only beds. There were major snoring issues, as well as what I used to call “The Deadly Wingspan”, to describe the large, manly elbows in my face in the middle of the night. It worked out for us, and I got lots more sleep, but then, we’re not married anymore either, so…

    • andy says:

      Ha ha ha ha ha ha! I’m torn on the subject, too. Not actually worried about our marriage, but just… I guess it would be nice if I wasn’t a sleestak doing the quickstep and she wasn’t such a light sleeper.

  • cupcake says:

    I know I’m in the minority here (and in the world), but I’m a huge proponent of doing whatever it takes to get the sleep you need to be healthy and happy. Life is too short to spend it exhausted. And sleep deprivation is not just an annoyance. It’s thought to be a major cause of vehicle accidents and makes it harder to lose weight (among other things).

    My husband and I have separate bedrooms, as our sleep needs are so different as to be irreconcilable. We have lots of intimate time, and either room can be a playpen, but when it’s time to sleep, I need my waterbed, body pillows, white noise, wrist guards, ice packs, ceiling fan, eye cover and cold packs. (Yes, very sexy, I know.) The hubs, on the other hand, needs a TV on, a semi-reclined and firm bed, 6 inches of personal space all around his prone body, assurance that no one startle him awake by touching him (yep, PTSD) and no one to complain when he snores… every time he falls asleep. Also, I work nights (12-hr shift) and sleep days, while the hubs sleeps when he can (due to post-vehicle-accident damage that won’t let him lay down for more than a couple of hours at a time). Since he doesn’t work outside the house, he can sleep when he is able, but I have to sleep when it’s sleeptime.

    It’s unconventional, but it works for us. Because we know sex and affection are not dependent on where we sleep… as long as we’re not sleeping with another person, that is!

    • andy says:

      Different strokes for different folks. Sleeping in the same bed is not as important as getting enough rest that the whole marriage doesn’t fly to pieces in the tumult of complete sleep deprivation. Also, seems like you’re rad for being all bionic about your separate sleep situation. πŸ˜‰

  • Amy says:

    Little known fact: a Standard King is actually w-i-d-e-r than a California King. Cal Kings are taller and less wide. So, if you’re desperate, you could gain four more glorious inches. πŸ™‚

  • marilee says:

    my husband and I have actually looked in to this. With early menopause and being super hot in my sleep and his body temp dropping at night, we cannot agree on room temp or bedding. We both snore and that isn’t really a factor. We are both mosh pit dancers in our sleep. I thought of twin beds but didn’t want to bring it up because I did not want him to feel the same way as you. However when he brought it up, I jumped all over it. We can at least stay in the same room instead of one of us camping out on the couch. I know that two beds will be much better than one queen.

    • Andy says:

      @ “mosh pit dancers in our sleep” LOL! Thanks for writing in and for the laugh. πŸ˜‰

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *